Everything on this page depends on Reddit reading your text as Markdown, and on new Reddit that is not the default. The desktop composer opens a rich text editor with a formatting toolbar, and it escapes Markdown characters as you type, so they arrive as literal asterisks. The composer carries a control for switching to the Markdown editor — usually labelled along the lines of "Switch to Markdown Editor" or "Markdown Mode", at the edge of the composer toolbar. Switching converts what you have already typed, so it is worth doing before you start rather than after.
Old Reddit, at old.reddit.com, has no rich text editor at all: every comment box is a Markdown box, which is part of why formatting-heavy communities still write there. If a comment refuses to format on the new site, writing it on the old one is a reliable escape hatch — the comment is the same comment either way, because what Reddit stores is the Markdown source.
The official mobile apps also offer a Markdown toggle in the post composer rather than defaulting to it, and third-party apps each make their own choice, so check the composer for a formatting or Markdown switch before assuming your syntax is wrong. Whichever editor you use, a comment written in Markdown mode still renders correctly for someone reading it in a rich text client.
Formatting works here — try editing this.
The twist is nobody saw it coming and the source is a comment from 2019.
old plannew planinline codestays literalLink to the wiki